Charitable purposes of a registered charity

Disclaimer

We do not guarantee the accuracy of this copy of the CRA website.

Scraped Page Content

Charitable purposes of a registered charity

Guidance

Reference number
CG-019

Issued
July 25, 2013 (Revised May 5, 2026)


General requirements for charitable registration


In addition to the requirements set out in this guidance, there are a number of other general requirements related to charitable registration. For more information, see Guidance CG-017, General requirements for charitable registration.

Guidance products can be updated. If you have comments or suggestions to improve the guidance, we would like to hear from you. To provide comments or obtain additional information, contact the Charities Directorate.


Other resources to help write charitable purposes


In addition to this guidance, the Canada Revenue Agency provides other resources to help you write charitable purposes in several ways:

This guidance focuses on the requirements for charitable purposes.

Summary

A registered charity must be constituted exclusively for charitable purposes and operated exclusively for charitable purposes. An organization’s purposes are stated in its governing document.

Charitable purposes are defined by the common law and the Income Tax Act.Footnote 1 This guidance explains how to write:

This guidance also explains the requirements that apply to both types of charitable purposes, as well as how the CRA determines whether purposes stated in a charity’s governing document are exclusively charitable.

Purposes charitable at common law

A purpose charitable at common law must:

  • fit within one of the four categories of charity
  • be for the benefit of the public

To ensure these requirements are met, a purpose must:

Image description

The three elements of a purpose charitable at common law:

  • Category of charity (What)
  • Scope of activities (How)
  • Eligible beneficiary group (Who)

Tip: When writing a purpose charitable at common law, we recommend that you include all three elements directly in the wording in order to avoid confusion or misinterpretation.

Purposes to make qualifying disbursements

In addition to purposes charitable at common law, the Income Tax Act considers that charitable purposes include making qualifying disbursements. Qualifying disbursements consist of:

  • making gifts or otherwise making resources available to qualified donees
  • making gifts or otherwise making resources available to grantee organizations in a way that meets the requirements of the Income Tax Act (commonly known as making grants to grantee organizations)

Note: To be a qualifying disbursement, a disbursement made to a grantee organization must further a stated purpose charitable at common law for which the charity is constituted.

Requirements for purposes charitable at common law and purposes to make qualifying disbursements

Image description

Charitable purposes

  • Purposes charitable at common law
    • Category or subcategory of charity (What)
    • Scope of activities (How)
    • Eligible beneficiary group (Who)
      • The charity must have a purpose charitable at common law
  • Making qualifying disbursements
    • Making qualifying disbursements to qualified donees
    • Making qualifying disbursements to non-qualified donees
      • The charity must have a purpose charitable at common law

1. Introduction

1. To be registered as a charity under the Income Tax Act, an organization must be constituted exclusively for charitable purposes and operate exclusively for these charitable purposes.Footnote 2 An organization’s purposes (objects, goals, or ends) are stated in its governing document.

2. A purpose is charitableFootnote 3 if it is:

Each type of charitable purpose has its own requirements.

3. To meet the requirement of having exclusively charitable purposes (the exclusivity requirement), every purpose stated in the charity’s governing document must be a charitable purpose. There is one exception to this requirement, which is explained in the section How the CRA determines whether a charity has exclusively charitable purposes.

Note: In this guidance, the term charity means a charity registered under the Income Tax Act or an organization applying to be a registered charity.

2. Purpose charitable at common law

4. To be charitable at common law, a purpose must:

  • fit within one of the four categories of charity
  • meet the public benefit requirement

For more information on the public benefit requirement, see Policy statement CPS-024, Guidelines for registering a charity: Meeting the public benefit test.

5. To meet the exclusivity requirement, the purpose must also limit the charity to use its resources only to further its charitable purpose and not any other non-charitable purpose.

6. To ensure these requirements are met, the wording of a purpose must:

When drafting a purpose, we recommend you clearly state all three elements. Each of these elements are explained in more detail below.

Example of purposes charitable at common law that state all three elements
Image description

Example 1

Category of charity (What): To relieve poverty

Scope of activities (How): By providing basic amenities

Eligible beneficiary group (Who): To the homeless

Example 2

Category of charity (What): To advance education

Scope of activities (How): By operating an elementary school

Eligible beneficiary group (Who): For children

2.1. Three elements of a charitable purpose

2.1.1. Category or subcategory of charity (What)

7. To be charitable at common law, a purpose must fit in one of the four categories of charity and be for the public benefit. The public benefit requirement applies differently depending on the category or subcategory of charity a purpose falls under.

8. The four categoriesFootnote 4 of charity are:

9. The fourth category includes a wide range of purposes that do not fit within the first three categories, but which the courts have recognized as charitable. These recognized purposes are grouped into several subcategories, including the promotion of health and the protection of the environment. See Appendix A - List of subcategories of other purposes beneficial to the community in a way the law regards as charitable.

10. To fit within one of the four categories of charity, the wording of a purpose must identify, implicitly or explicitly, a category or subcategory of charity. To do so, the category or subcategory of charity may simply be stated in the purpose, or it may be inferredFootnote 5 from one or both of the other two elements in the wording of the purpose:

Note: A charity can be constituted for purposes that fit in different categories or subcategories of charity. However, each purpose should identify only one category or subcategory of charity.

Example of charitable purposes with an inferred category of charity

In the following two examples, the purpose does not state a specific category of charity. However, the category can be inferred based on the two other elements.

Image description

Example 1

Defined

Scope of activities (How): To operate a food bank

Eligible beneficiary group (Who): For people in need

Inferred

Category of charity (What): Relief of poverty

Example 2

Defined

Scope of activities (How): To produce public arts exhibitions, presentations, and performance arts events

Eligible beneficiary group (Who): For the public

Inferred

Subcategory of charity (What): To advance the public's appreciation of the arts

2.1.2. Scope of activities (How)

11. To meet the requirement to be constituted and operated for exclusively charitable purposes, a charity must state its purposes in a way that ensures its resources can only be used to further charitable purposes, and not for any non-charitable purpose. The purpose must clearly define the scope of the activities the charity can carry out, and that scope must be limited to charitable activities only.Footnote 6

12. When drafting a purpose, defining a scope of activities generally means outlining the range of activities that the charity can carry on to further the purpose. However, it does not require listing every possible charitable activity the charity can carry out.

For example, if a charity’s purpose is “to promote health by operating a hospital,” the following activities would fall within that scope, even though they are not listed individually in the purpose:

  • establishing and maintaining a hospital facility
  • hiring and training medical personnel
  • providing an emergency room and diagnostic services
  • conducting a residency program for physicians

13. A charitable purpose can be stated broadly, as long as it limits the charity to carrying out only charitable activities.Footnote 7 However, if a purpose authorizes the charity to carry out both charitable activities and non-charitable activities, it is too broad and therefore not charitable. A purpose that does not define a scope of activities is vague and therefore also not charitable. See Purposes that are too broad or vague.Footnote 8

Example of charitable purposes with a broad scope of activities
Example of charitable purposes with a broad scope of activities
Charitable purposes Analysis
To relieve poverty by providing necessities of life and simple amenities to people experiencing poverty. This purpose is broad because it authorizes a wide range of activities that relieve poverty, but it is not too broad because it does not authorize non-charitable activities.
To promote health by preventing the occurrence of heart disease. This purpose is broad because it authorizes a wide range of activities that promote health, but it is not too broad because it does not authorize non-charitable activities.

14. A charitable purpose can also define a scope of activities that is narrow. However, a purpose that is narrowly worded may not authorize all the charitable activities a charity carries on or plans to carry on. This can reduce the charity’s flexibility to respond to changing needs or pursue other activities to further its purposes. For this reason, we generally do not recommend drafting purposes that are overly narrow.

Example of a charitable purpose with a narrow scope of activities
Example of a charitable purpose with a narrow scope of activities
Charitable purposes Analysis
To advance education by providing an online course on financial literacy to elementary students. Although this purpose is charitable, it is narrow. Its scope of activities does not authorize the charity to carry out other types of educational activities, cover different subjects, or serve a broader eligible beneficiary group.

2.1.3. Eligible beneficiary group (Who)

15. For a purpose to be charitable at common law, it must meet the public benefit requirement. The public component of the public benefit requirement requires the benefit of the purpose to be directed to the public or a sufficient section of the public. To determine this, we look at who benefits from the purpose, meaning the group of individuals who is eligible to receive the benefit – this is the eligible beneficiary group.

For more information on what constitutes a sufficient section of the community, see Policy statement CPS-024, Guidelines for registering a charity: Meeting the public benefit test.

16. The public benefit requirement varies depending on the category of charity. There are different requirements to determine if an eligible beneficiary group constitutes the community or a sufficient section of the community, depending on the category of charity in which the purpose fits.

17. Sometimes, restricting eligible beneficiaries is justified, or even required, based on the nature of the purpose. Other times, benefits must be available to the community as a whole. For example, poverty relief purposes must be restricted to people experiencing poverty; a women’s shelter may justify restricting its eligible beneficiaries to women; and health organizations addressing a particular disease may restrict eligible beneficiaries to people afflicted with that disease. On the other hand, general hospitals and community centres should usually be available to the community as a whole.

18. To meet the public component, we must be able to identify an eligible beneficiary group (Who) from the wording of a purpose, and this group must be the community or a sufficient section of the community. To do this, the eligible beneficiary group may simply be stated in the purpose, or it may be inferredFootnote 9 from one or both of the purpose’s other two elements:

19. A purpose that does not identify (implicitly or explicitly) an appropriate eligible beneficiary group does not meet the public component of the public benefit requirement and therefore is not charitable.

Examples of purposes that identify an appropriate eligible beneficiary group
Examples of purposes that identify an appropriate eligible beneficiary group
Charitable purposes Analysis
To advance education by operating an elementary school for children in the town of ABC.
  • Restricting the eligible beneficiary group to children is relevant to achieving the charitable purpose of advancing education by operating an elementary school.
  • Also, reasonable geographic restrictions are acceptable for all categories of charity.
To relieve conditions attributable to aging by providing specially adapted residential accommodation, incidental facilities, and support to older persons with limited mobility.
  • Restricting the eligible beneficiary group to aged persons with limited mobility is justified (relevant) to achieving the purpose of relieving conditions attributable to aging.

2.2. A purpose cannot be too broad or vague

20. A purpose that is too broad or vague is not charitable.

21. A purpose is too broad when it allows both charitable and non-charitable activities.Footnote 10 In other words, the purpose may allow the charity to use its resources to further charitable purposes, but it is stated so broadly it may also allow activities that further non-charitable purposes.

22. A purpose is vague when:

  • it is ambiguous or uncertain;
  • it does not fit within one of the four categories of charity; or
  • it does not define a scope of activitiesFootnote 11
Examples of purposes the CRA considers too broad or vague vs charitable purposes
Examples of purposes the CRA considers too broad or vague vs charitable purposes
Purposes that are too broad or vague Charitable purposes

To relieve poverty through various means.

  • Too broad and vague — the phrase “through various means” is ambiguous and uncertain

To relieve poverty by operating a food bank.

  • what — to relieve poverty
  • how — by operating a food bank
  • who — inferred: people experiencing poverty

To provide money to students.

  • Too broad and vague — it is not clear why money is being provided to students, making it unclear whether the purpose fits within a category or subcategory of charity and therefore allowing for both charitable and non-charitable activities

To advance education by providing scholarships to students.

  • what — to advance education
  • how — by providing scholarships
  • who — students

To advance religion in developing countries.

  • Vague — the religion to be advanced is not identified and the scope of activities is not defined

To advance (specify religion) in developing countries by establishing and maintaining schools of religious instruction for children, youths, and adults.

  • what — to advance religion
  • how — establishing and maintaining schools of religious instruction
  • who — children, youths, and adults

To build strong communities after disasters.

  • Too broad —the purpose allows for both charitable and non charitable activities
  • Vague — the phrase “to build strong communities” is ambiguous and uncertain and the charitable category or subcategory cannot be identified

To improve socio-economic conditions and prevent community deterioration in (specify areas of deprivation) by providing financial assistance to residents affected by the disaster.

  • what — to improve socio-economic conditions and prevent community deterioration
  • how — providing financial assistance
  • who — residents affected by the disaster

To promote the health of Canadians.

  • Vague — the scope of activities is not defined

To promote health by operating a healthy-heart program.

  • what — to promote health
  • how — operating a healthy-heart program
  • who — patients suffering from cardiovascular disease and the public

To relieve poverty by providing financial counselling and loan forgiveness to individuals with high consumer debt.

  • Too broad — it allows for both charitable and non-charitable activities, as individuals with high consumer debt are not necessarily experiencing povertyFootnote 13

To relieve poverty by providing financial counselling and assistance to individuals and families experiencing poverty.

  • what — to relieve poverty
  • how — providing financial counselling and assistance
  • who — individuals and families experiencing poverty

2.3. Special topics

2.3.1. Public policy dialogue and development activities

23. A charity can carry on public policy dialogue and development activities (PPDDAs) to further its charitable purposes. Footnote 13 However, PPDDAs do not themselves constitute charitable purposes. This is because political purposes are not charitable at law,Footnote 14 and PPDDAs are only permitted as a means of furthering a charitable purpose. As such, a charity should avoid stating PPDDAs in its purposes.

For more information on PPDDAs and examples of charitable purposes, see Guidance CG-027, Public policy dialogue and development activities by charities.

2.3.2. Related business activities

24. A charity designated as a charitable organization or a public foundation can carry on a related business. A related business is a business that is linked and subordinate to a charitable purpose, or a business that is run substantially all by volunteers.Footnote 15 However, carrying on a business is not a charitable purpose in itself. Accordingly, if a charity intends to carry on a related business, it should avoid stating it in its purposes.

For more information about carrying on a related business see: Policy statement CPS-019, What is a related business?

3. Purposes to make qualifying disbursements

25. In addition to purposes charitable at common law, the Income Tax Act considers that charitable purposes include making qualifying disbursements.Footnote 16 Purposes to make qualifying disbursements consist of:

Note: Any disbursement made to a grantee organization must be made in furtherance of a purpose charitable at common law that is stated in the charity’s governing document.

Image description

Qualifying disbursements

  • Disbursements to qualified donees
  • Disbursements to non-qualified donees
    • The disbursements furthers a purpose of the charity that is charitable at common law

3.1. Making qualifying disbursements to qualified donees

26. Making qualifying disbursements to qualified donees is a charitable purpose under the Income Tax Act.Footnote 17

27. Making a qualifying disbursement to a qualified donee means making a gift or otherwise making resources available to a qualified donee.

28. A charity can draft a purpose to make qualifying disbursements to qualified donees in many ways, as long as the recipients are limited to organizations that are qualified donees. The purpose may be restricted to gifting to specific qualified donees, like registered charities for example, or include all qualified donees. Charities should, however, look into the requirements of their corporate registrars, where appropriate, as some jurisdictions may have specific rules for how such purposes must include in their wording.Footnote 18

Examples of charitable purposes to make qualifying disbursements to qualified donees

The following are examples of charitable purposes to make qualifying disbursements to qualified donees:

  • To receive and maintain a fund or funds and to apply all or part of the principal and income therefrom, from time to time, to qualified donees as defined in subsection 149.1(1) of the Income Tax Act.
  • To make gifts, from time to time, to charitable organizations that are registered charities.
  • To make qualifying disbursements to qualified donees.

3.2. Making qualifying disbursements to grantee organizations (non-qualified donees)

29. Making qualifying disbursements to grantee organizationsFootnote 19 is a charitable purpose under the Income Tax Act. However, such a purpose does not, on its own, authorize a charity to make qualifying disbursements to a grantee organization. That is because a disbursement made to a grantee organization must further a charity’s stated purpose that is charitable at common law in order to be a qualifying disbursement.Footnote 20 As such, to make a qualifying disbursement to a grantee organization, a charity must be constituted for a purpose charitable at common law.

30. A stated purpose that is charitable at common law can explicitly refer to making qualifying disbursements to grantee organizations but doesn’t need to. Including wording that expressly refers to making qualifying disbursements limits how a charity can further its charitable purpose. A charity constituted for a purpose charitable at common law is fully authorized to make qualifying disbursements in furtherance of that purpose.

For more information on qualifying disbursements to grantee organizations, see Guidance CG-032, Registered charities making grants to non-qualified donees.

Image description

Charitable purposes

  • Purposes charitable at common law
    • Category or subcategory of charity (What)
    • Scope of activities (How)
    • Eligible beneficiary group (Who)
  • Making qualifying disbursements
    • Making qualifying disbursements to qualified donees
    • Making qualifying disbursements to non-qualified donees
      • The charity must have a purpose charitable at common law

Tips related to including wording to make qualifying disbursements in a purpose

Tips:

The purpose “To make grants to grantee organizations” is not a charitable purpose. It authorizes more than qualifying disbursements, as the term “grant” has a common meaning that is not restricted to qualifying disbursements as defined in the Income Tax Act.

Only grants to grantee organizations that meet the accountability requirements set out in the Income Tax Act are qualifying disbursements.

As such, if a charity wants to include wording in its purpose charitable at common law regarding the making of grants to grantee organizations, the wording must clearly restrict the charity to making qualifying disbursements to grantee organizations. For example, a charity’s purpose may be worded as follows:

  • To relieve poverty by providing basic necessities of life to people experiencing poverty through the making of qualifying disbursements to grantee organizations.
  • To relieve poverty by providing basic necessities of life to people experiencing poverty by making grants that are qualifying disbursements.

Examples of purposes charitable at common law that authorize making qualifying disbursements to grantee organizations

The following are examples of purposes charitable at common law that authorize making qualifying disbursements to grantee organizations:

  • To advance [specify religion] in developing countries by establishing and maintaining schools of religious instruction for children, youths, and adults.
  • To advance [specify religion] in developing countries by establishing and maintaining schools of religious instruction for children, youths, and adults by making qualifying disbursements to grantee organizations.
  • To make qualifying disbursements to grantee organizations in furtherance of the following purposes:
    • to promote health by operating a healthy-heart program
    • to address youth unemployment by providing employment-related skills programs

Analysis

All three examples are purposes charitable at common law that allow (implicitly or explicitly) making qualifying disbursements to grantee organizations.

Example of a charity constituted for a charitable purpose that cannot make qualifying disbursements to grantee organizations

The following is an example of a charity constituted for a charitable purpose that cannot make qualifying disbursements to grantee organizations.

A charity is constituted for only the following purpose:

  • To receive and maintain a fund or funds and to apply all or part of the principal and income therefrom, from time to time, to make qualifying disbursements to grantee organizations.

Analysis

This purpose is considered charitable by the Income Tax Act.

However, in order to make a qualifying disbursement, the charity would need to be constituted for a purpose charitable at common law.

4. How the CRA determines whether a charity has exclusively charitable purposes

31. To determine whether a charity is constituted for exclusively charitable purposes, the CRA will examine each purpose stated in the charity’s governing document and determine if they are charitable, in accordance with the common law and Income Tax Act requirements set out in this guidance.

32. To meet the “exclusively” requirement, each of the charity’s purposes must be a charitable purpose and only allow it to use its resources towards activities that further charitable purposes.

33. However, there is a limited exception to this rule, that we refer to as the common law incidental purposes doctrine. If a stated purpose or part of a purpose is not charitable in itself, the charity may still be considered to be constituted for exclusively charitable purposes if that purpose is incidental to a charitable purpose of the charity. A purpose is incidental when it is only a way to support, facilitate or contribute to a charity’s ability to further its other purposes that are charitable. In other words, if the purpose is better understood as an activity that the charity carries out to further its charitable purposes, the CRA will not consider the charity to have a non-charitable purpose.Footnote 21

34. Therefore, the CRA will consider that a charity’s stated purposes are exclusively charitable if each of them is one of the following:

  • a purpose charitable at common law
  • a purpose to make qualifying disbursements
  • a purpose that is incidental to the furtherance of a charitable purpose of the organization

35. To confirm the organization is constituted for exclusively charitable purposes, the CRA will also look at the organization’s activities to confirm that it does not have any unstated non-charitable purposes.Footnote 22

Application of the common law incidental purposes doctrine

The following is an example of the application of the common law incidental purposes doctrine:

A charity is constituted for the following purposes:

  1. To promote the welfare of animals for the benefit of the public by:
    • operating a shelter for stray, abandoned, abused, or surrendered animals;
    • operating an animal adoption program.
  2. To promote the shelter and its adoption program to the public.
  3. To raise funds to support the operation of the shelter.

Analysis

Purpose a. is charitable at common law:

  • It fits within the fourth category of charity, and authorizes only charitable activities— operating a shelter for stray, abandoned, abused of surrendered animals and operating an animal adoption program.

Purposes b. and c. are incidental purposes. They are only a way to support, facilitate or contribute to the organization’s ability to further its charitable purpose of promoting the welfare of animals.

Therefore, we can consider that the organization’s stated purposes are exclusively charitable.

Example of a charity constituted for stated purposes that are exclusively charitable
Image description

Purpose charitable at common law

  • To advance the public's appreciation of the arts by producing public visual art exhibitions and events and by providing a forum for qualified artists to exhibit, present, or perform their artistic works through participation in such events.

Purpose charitable at common law

  • To advance education by providing visual art classes, seminars, and workshops to the public.

Purpose to make qualifying disbursement (considered charitable by the Income Tax Act)

  • To receive and maintain a fund or funds and to apply all or part of the principal and income therefrom, from time to time, to qualified donees as defined in subsection 149.1(1) of the Income Tax Act (Canada).

Purpose that is incidental to the other charitable purposes

  • To raise funds to accomplish the above objects.

5. Other considerations

5.1. Updating your charity’s purposes

36. You can update the purposes stated in your charity’s governing document to:

  • amend a purpose
  • delete a purpose
  • add a purpose

37. Common reasons for updating purposes include:

  • your charity carries on or plans to carry on activities that are not authorized by its current purposes.
  • your charity plans on making qualifying disbursements to grantee organizations but is constituted only for a purpose to make gifts to qualified donees.

38. After updating your charity’s purposes, we recommend you send your charity’s updated governing document to the Charities Directorate. This keeps your charity’s file with the CRA accurate and up to date. We may review these changes at a later date and contact you if we have concerns or need further information.

For more information on how to report updates to your purposes, go to Change purposes and activities.

5.2. Powers clauses

39. Powers clauses generally set out an organization’s authority to manage its affairs or grow its property and income. Powers clauses often follow an organization’s stated purposes in its governing document.

40. Examples of powers clauses include the authority or power to:

  • buy, hold, and sell property
  • employ and pay staff, and appoint intermediaries
  • make investments
  • borrow money
  • enter into contracts

41. The Income Tax Act does not require a charity to include powers clauses in its governing document. A powers clause poses no concerns unless it:

  • explicitly allows the organization to further a non‑charitable purpose
  • requires the organization to operate in a way that contravenes the Income Tax Act
Examples of unacceptable powers clauses for a charity

The following are examples of unacceptable powers clauses for a charity:

To do all such things that are incidental to the organization’s charitable purposes, including:

  1. paying dividends to shareholders
  2. distributing surplus income to its members, directors, or shareholders, as decided by the Board of Directors.

Analysis:

Clauses a. and b. allow the charity to further a non-charitable purpose to make profit.

They further contravene the Income Tax Act requirement that no part of the income of a charity should be payable to, or made available for the personal benefit of its proprietors, members, or shareholders.

5.3. Requirements from other sources

42. In addition to meeting the requirements of the Income Tax Act, a charity, or its governing document, may also be subject to requirements set out in its incorporating statute, and other federal, provincial, or territorial legislation.

43. For example, some incorporating statutes may recommend or require standard purposes that are not charitable. An organization constituted with such a purpose is not eligible for registration as a charity.

For more information, consult your corporate registrar or other authority responsible for incorporating your organization.

6. Version history

Version history
Version number Revision Reason for revision Issued
2.0
  • Redrafted the guidance to set out the legal requirements for charitable purposes in a way that better aligns with the Supreme Court decision in Vancouver Society of Immigrant and Visible Minority Women v M.N.R., 1999 1 SCR 10
  • Explained the common law incidental purposes doctrine.
  • Added information on purposes to make qualifying disbursements, and provided examples and explanations to clarify them.
  • Made plain language edits, updated terminology, reorganized content, added examples, and removed duplicate content.
  • Added an appendix A with a list of subcategories of charity.
  • Periodic review
  • Closer alignment with the Supreme Court of Canada’s decision Vancouver Society of Immigrant and Visible Minority Women v M.N.R., 1999 1 SCR 10
  • Introduction of qualifying disbursements in the Income Tax Act.
Revised May 5, 2026
1.0
  • First version of the guidance product
  • New
July 25, 2013

References


Footnote 1

The Income Tax Act and the common law are the two sources of charitable purposes. A purpose charitable at common law meets specific criteria of the common law, including the fact it must be for the public benefit. A purpose to make qualifying disbursements is charitable because the Income Tax Act deems it to be charitable.

Return to footnote1 referrer

Footnote 2

The Income Tax Act requires a charity to be “constituted” and “operated” exclusively for charitable purposes.

In subsection 149.1(1), it defines “charitable organization”:

charitable organization, at any particular time, means an organization, whether or not incorporated,

constituted and operated exclusively for charitable purposes

[. . .]

[Emphasis added]

and “charitable foundation”:

charitable foundation means a corporation or trust that is constituted and operated exclusively for charitable purposes, no part of the income of which is payable to, or is otherwise available for, the personal benefit of any proprietor, member, shareholder, trustee or settlor thereof, and that is not a charitable organization; (fondation de bienfaisance)

[Emphasis added]

Return to footnote2 referrer

Footnote 3

The Income Tax Act does not provide an exhaustive definition of what constitutes a charitable purpose. Subsection 149.1(1) only defines charitable purposes as including “making qualifying disbursements.” As a result, the CRA also relies on the common law (that is, court decisions) to determine whether a purpose is charitable.

Return to footnote3 referrer

Footnote 4

The four categories of charity were outlined by Lord Macnaghten in The Commissioners for Special Purposes of the Income Tax v Pemsel, 1891 AC 531 (PC). This classification was first explicitly approved of by the Supreme Court of Canada in Guaranty Trust Co. of Canada v. Minister of National Revenue, [1967] S.C.R. 133, and confirmed in Vancouver Society v. Minister of National Revenue, [1999] 1 S.C.R. 10 (Vancouver Society).

Return to footnote4 referrer

Footnote 5

See Halsbury, 3rd ed, vol 4, at paragraph 495, and cases there cited. As well as the following cases:

  • Re Gillespie, 1965 VR 402 (S Ct of Victoria), at page 406, per Little J:

Poverty need not be expressly mentioned in the terms of the gift for an unexpressed intention to relieve poverty may be inferred from the nature of the gift

  • In Re Lucas, 1922 2 Ch 52 at page 59, 1922 All ER Rep 317, per Russell, J

A purpose charitable at common law always defines the scope of activities. It is possible that from the context of the scope of activities, the category or subcategory of charity and the eligible beneficiary group can be inferred. For example, the stated purpose “to operate a soup kitchen” is usually understood to fit within the relief of poverty category of charity, for persons experiencing poverty. As such, the category or subcategory of charity and the eligible beneficiary group can be inferred.

In most cases, however, for the category or subcategory of charity or the eligible beneficiary group to be inferred, a charitable purpose must state either the category or subcategory of charity or the eligible beneficiary group along with defining the scope of activities. For example, the purpose “to provide housing” is not charitable. Providing housing can further a purpose that fits in any of the four categories of charity, or even a profit purpose. On the other hand, the purpose “to provide housing to those experiencing poverty” is charitable because, from the wording of the purpose, the category of charity — to relieve poverty — can be inferred.

Return to footnote5 referrer

Footnote 6

See the following cases:

  • Vancouver Society of Immigrant and Visible Minority Women v M.N.R., 1999 1 SCR 10 (Vancouver Society), at paragraph 163, per Iacobucci J:

[163] [. . .] the Federal Court of Appeal was justified in finding that the Society’s activities were not charitable under this heading, and consequently that the purposes clause, to the extent that it contemplated such activities, did not restrict the Society to charitable activities for the advancement of education.

and at paragraph 204, per Iacobucci J:

[204] [. . .] I am of the view that the purposes of the Society do not restrict it to charitable activities, and thus that the Society cannot be viewed as being constituted exclusively for charitable purposes.

  • Travel Just v Canada Revenue Agency, 2006 FCJ No 1599, 2006 FCA 343, paragraphs 3 and 10, per Evans J.A.:

[3] If, as a matter of construction, Travel Just’s corporate objects permit it to spend its funds on activities that are not legally charitable, it may not be registered as a charity. [. . .] If, on the other hand, the objects confine it to charitable activities, Travel Just will be entitled to be registered.

[10] In a word, laudable as the objects listed in (a) may be, they are too broad and vague. It cannot be said that they restrict Travel Just’s expenditures to purposes that are in law charitable.

  • STV Stop the Violence...Face the Music Society v Her Majesty the Queen, 1996-12-05 (STV Stop the Violence), at paragraph 4, per McDonald, J.A.:

[4] In this case S.T.V.’s stated goals and objectives are broad and loosely defined. While such far-reaching goals are commendable, they do not satisfy the test in law that the stated purpose of the organization be sufficiently specific to enable the Minister to be satisfied that the organization will be engaged in and will direct all of its resources to charitable activities.

Return to footnote6 referrer

Footnote 7

Native Communications Society of B.C. v. Canada (M.N.R.) (F.C.A.), 1986 CanLII 6817 (FCA), [1986] 3 FC 471, at p 484:

I have concluded that the appellant’s purposes are beneficial to the Indian community of British Columbia within the spirit and intendment of the preamble to the Statute of Elizabeth and, therefore, they are good charitable purposes. It is true that they are not drawn with exceptional precision, but it is of the nature of corporate objects clauses to be rather broadly phrased. Nevertheless, they are restricted to matters that are “of relevance” or are “relevant” or that are “facing native people of B.C..”

Return to footnote7 referrer

Footnote 8

Earth Fund v Canada (Minister of National Revenue), 2002 FCA 498 (Earth Fund), paragraphs 24 to 25, per Sharlow J.A.:

[24] Section 8 on its face is broad enough to authorize the appellant to fund environmental and humanitarian projects undertaken by organizations that are not “qualified donees”. It is also broad enough to permit the appellant to fund a commercial venture aimed at exploiting a renewable source of energy, which presumably would benefit the environment, with or without sharing in any potential profits from the venture. Indeed, section 8 is so broad that it would permit the appellant to carry on such a commercial enterprise itself, and section 7 would permit the appellant to accumulate its profits without making any distributions at all, even to qualified donees.

[25] It does not matter that the appellant claims to have no present intention of doing any of these things. The problem is that its objects are so broad that it could do them, and therefore it is impossible to conclude that the appellant is constituted exclusively for charitable purposes.

Return to footnote8 referrer

Footnote 9

Supra, note 5

Return to footnote9 referrer

Footnote 10

It does not matter that a charity does not have the intention to carry out non-charitable activities. If the purpose allows them, the charity is not constituted for exclusively charitable purposes. See Earth Fund, supra note 8

Also see the following cases:

  • STV Stop the Violence, supra note 6
  • Volgograd Committee v Minister of National Revenue, (1988) 88 D
  • Earth Fund, supra note 6
  • re Orr [1917] OJ No 497
  • re Bain Public Trustee v Ross 1928 B 518.

Return to footnote10 referrer

Footnote 11

See Vancouver Society, supra note 6, at paragraph 159:

In conclusion, on the basis of the Canadian jurisprudence, the requirements for registration under s. 248(1) come down to two:

(1) the purposes of the organization must be charitable, and must define the scope of the activities engaged in by the organization; and

…

[emphasis added]

Return to footnote11 referrer

Footnote 12

Credit Counselling Services of Atlantic Canada Inc. v Canada (National Revenue), 2016 FCA 193 [2017] 1 FCR 480.

Return to footnote12 referrer

Footnote 13

Subsection 149.1(1) of the Income Tax Act defines “charitable activities”:

charitable activities includes public policy dialogue and development activities carried on in furtherance of a charitable purpose; (activités de bienfaisance)

Return to footnote13 referrer

Footnote 14

The common law provides that political purposes are not charitable (see: McGovern et al. v Attorney- General et al., [1982] 1 Ch. 321, [1981] 3 All ER 493; N.D.G. Neighbourhood Association v. Revenue Canada, Taxation Department, 88 D.T.C. 6279 (FCA); Positive Action Against Pornography v. M.N.R., [1988] 2 FC 340; Toronto Volgograd Committee v. M.N.R., [1988] 3 FC 251).

Political purposes include those that seek either of the following:

  • further the interests of a particular political party or support a political party or candidate for public office
  • retain, oppose, or change the law, policy, or decision of any level of government in Canada or a foreign country

Return to footnote14 referrer

Footnote 15

Subsection 149.1(1) of the Income Tax Act defines “related business”:

related business, in relation to a charity or Canadian amateur athletic association, includes a business that is unrelated to the purposes of the charity or association if substantially all persons employed by the charity or association in the carrying on of that business are not remunerated for that employment; (activité commerciale complémentaire)

This means that a related business is either a business that is related to a charitable purpose (linked and subordinate), or a business that is unrelated to the charitable purpose but run substantially all by volunteers.

Return to footnote15 referrer

Footnote 16

Subsection 149.1(1) of the Income Tax Act defines “qualifying disbursement”:

qualifying disbursement means a disbursement by a charity, by way of a gift or by otherwise making resources available,

(a) subject to subsection 149.1(6.001) of the Income Tax Act, to a qualified donee, or

(b) to a grantee organization, if

(i) the disbursement is in furtherance of a charitable purpose (determined without reference to the definition charitable purposes in this subsection) of the charity,

(ii) the charity ensures that the disbursement is exclusively applied to charitable activities in furtherance of a charitable purpose of the charity, and

(iii) the charity maintains documentation sufficient to demonstrate

(A) the purpose for which the disbursement is made, and

(B) that the disbursement is exclusively applied by the grantee organization to charitable activities in furtherance of a charitable purpose of the charity; (versement admissible)

Return to footnote16 referrer

Footnote 17

Supra note 16

Return to footnote17 referrer

Footnote 18

A charity subject to specific charity law applicable to Ontario may not be allowed to makes gifts to a qualified donee other than a charitable organization. For more information, contact the Office of the Public Guardian and Trustee.

Return to footnote18 referrer

Footnote 19

Subsection 149.1(1) of the Income Tax Act defines “grantee organization”:

grantee organization includes a person, club, society, association or organization or prescribed entity, but does not include a qualified donee

Return to footnote19 referrer

Footnote 20

Pursuant to subparagraph (b)(i) of the definition “qualifying disbursement” in subsection 149.1(1) of the Income Tax Act, a disbursement to a grantee organization is only a qualifying disbursement if it is made in furtherance of a charitable purpose determined without reference to the definition “charitable purposes” in subsection 149.1(1)), which reads:

charitable purposes includes making qualifying disbursements; (fins de bienfaisance)

This means a charity can only make a qualifying disbursement to a grantee organization in furtherance of a stated purpose that is charitable at common law, and not in furtherance of a stated purpose to make qualifying disbursements. As such, to make a qualifying disbursement to a grantee organization, the charity must be constituted with a purpose that is charitable according to common law.

Return to footnote20 referrer

Footnote 21

See Vancouver Society, supra note 6, at paragraphs 157-158, citing Guaranty Trust Co of Canada v Minister of National Revenue, [1967] S.C.R. 133 (Guaranty Trust), per Iacobucci J:

158 The chief proposition to be drawn from this holding is that even the pursuit of a purpose which would be non‑charitable in itself may not disqualify an organization from being considered charitable if it is pursued only as a means of fulfilment of another, charitable, purpose and not as an end in itself. That is, where the purpose is better construed as an activity in direct furtherance of a charitable purpose, the organization will not fail to qualify as charitable because it described the activity as a purpose.

[Emphasis added]

The common law’s incidental purposes doctrine is also referenced in Travel Just, supra note 6, at paragraph 3, per Evans JA:

[3] If, as a matter of construction, Travel Just’s corporate objects permit it to spend its funds on activities that are not legally charitable, it may not be registered as a charity: Earth Fund/Fond pour la Terre v. Canada (Minister of National Revenue), 2002 FCA 498 at para. 20. This principle is subject to the limited statutory exception [. . .], and the common law’s incidental purposes doctrine:

[Emphasis added]

Return to footnote21 referrer

Footnote 22

See Vancouver Society, supra note 6, at paragraphs 194-195, relying on Guaranty Trust.

Return to footnote22 referrer


Page details

2013-07-24