Search - 包建铎违纪违法案件以案促改以案促治专题组织生活会 个人对照检查

. … PCI justifiably submitted that the position adopted by the ARQ, that the SADI Agreement was a forgivable loan given that the required repayments were a function of the growth in future revenues (so that the obligation to repay depended on the occurrence of an uncertain and future event), was a position which was relied upon in the dissent and rejected by the majority in McLarty. ...

. … The analogy with the Kellogg and Evans cases is not perfect, because the former involved a business and the latter involved income from a trust, but it is sufficient to convince us that an expense is not capital in nature simply because the expense is not recurring or extraordinary. ...

It did so 505 times in the relevant period…” (para. 55) “I accept, of course, that the enduring nature of an outgoing is a very relevant matter … but I do not think that the five year term obtained under the contracts here was of such a nature. ...

The relevant dicta are mainly collected in a summary by Lord Walker in DCC Holdings (UK) Ltd v Revenue and Customs Comrs [2011] 1 WLR 44, paras 37-39 …: (1) The extent of the fiction created by a deeming provision is primarily a matter of construction of the statute in which it appears. (2) For that purpose the court should ascertain, if it can, the purposes for which and the persons between whom the statutory fiction is to be resorted to, and then apply the deeming provision that far, but not where it would produce effects clearly outside those purposes. (3) But those purposes may be difficult to ascertain, and Parliament may not find it easy to prescribe with precision the intended limits of the artificial assumption which the deeming provision requires to be made. (4) A deeming provision should not be applied so far as to produce unjust, absurd or anomalous results, unless the court is compelled to do so by clear language. (5) But the court should not shrink from applying the fiction created by the deeming provision to the consequences which would inevitably flow from the fiction being real. ...

. … Splitting the ownership of the building and the ownership of 9118, which continued to operate the [residence], had only one goal, to minimize the taxes payable. ...

At the time the plaintiff filed his return in April 1999 for his 1998 taxation year, he did not retain a taxable benefit resulting from his conduct for which he ultimately was found to be criminally responsible …. ...

In summarizing this arrangement, Hogue, J.C.A. stated (at para. 42, TaxInterpretations translation): … [T]he agreed formula means that PCI must repay the advances received over 15 years if its revenues are stable. ...

The ARQ reassessed to deny the deduction by Mobile of legal and accounting fees incurred by it in investigating the disappearance of the sales proceeds and in relation to the Superior Court action, primarily on the basis that they were capital expenditures (TA, s. 129, similar to ITA s. 18(1)(b) – although TA s. 128, similar to ITA s. 18(1)(a), was also invoked). ...

. … The time limits for the assessment and collection of the tax debt are all expressly provided for in the TA and the TAA. ...

. … Regarding the IPT, section 527 of the QSTA clearly provides that the insurer, in its capacity as agent, must account for the tax collected in the preceding calendar month at the end of the month. ...