Date: 20131220
Docket:
T-1708-12
Citation: 2013
FC 1272
Ottawa, Ontario,
December 20, 2013
PRESENT:    The
Honourable Mr. Justice Barnes
BETWEEN:
| 
   
 | 
 GILEAD SCIENCES, INC. AND 
GILEAD SCIENCES CANADA, INC. 
  
 | 
   
 | 
| 
   
 | 
 Applicants 
  
 | 
| 
 and 
  
  
 | 
   
 | 
| 
 THE MINISTER OF HEALTH AND 
TEVA CANADA LIMITED 
  
 | 
   
 | 
| 
   
 | 
 Respondents 
  
 | 
 
           REASONS FOR
JUDGMENT AND JUDGMENT
 
[1]              
For
the Reasons given in Federal Court file T-8-12, citation 2013 FC 1270, this
application is similarly decided.  
JUDGMENT
THIS
COURT’S JUDGMENT is that:  
 
a)                 
The
application is allowed in part;
 
b)                 
The
Minister is prohibited from issuing a Notice of Compliance to Teva in respect
of its tenofovir disoproxil fumarate product until the expiry of Canadian
Letters Patent 2, 261,619; and 
 
c)                 
The
issue of costs is reserved pending further written submissions from the
parties.  
 
 
"R.L.
Barnes"
 
FEDERAL COURT
 
SOLICITORS OF RECORD
 
 
DOCKET:                                         T-1708-12
 
STYLE OF CAUSE:                        GILEAD
SCIENCES, INC. AND GILEAD SCIENCES CANADA, INC. 
                                                            v
                                                            THE
MINISTER OF HEALTH AND TEVA CANADA LIMITED
 
PLACE OF HEARING:                  Toronto, ON
 
DATE OF HEARING:                    September
9 to 16, 2013
 
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT:      BARNES J.
 
DATED:                                            December
20, 2013
 
 
 
APPEARANCES:
 
| 
 Patrick E. Kierans 
Louisa
  Pontrelli 
Brian
  Daley 
Nisha
  Anand 
Brian John Capogrosso  
  
 | 
 FOR THE APPLICANTS 
  
 | 
| 
 Jonathan Stainsby 
William P. Mayo 
Lesley Caswell 
Andrew McIntyre  
  
 | 
 FOR THE RESPONDENT 
TEVA CANADA LIMITED 
  
 | 
 
SOLICITORS OF RECORD:
 
| 
 Norton Rose Fulbright Canada LLP 
Toronto, ON 
  
 | 
 FOR THE APPLICANTS 
 | 
 
| 
 Heenan Blaikie LLP 
Toronto, ON  
  
 | 
 FOR THE RESPONDENT 
TEVA CANADA LIMITED 
  
 | 
| 
 William
  F. Pentney 
Deputy
  Attorney General of Canada 
Montreal, QC 
  
 | 
 FOR THE RESPONDENT 
THE MINISTER OF
  HEALTH 
 |