Hodgson v. Musqueam Indian Band, 2017 FC 579

Date: 20170613

Docket: T-1912-15

Citation: 2017 FC 579

Ottawa, Ontario, June 13, 2017

PRESENT:    The Honourable Madam Justice Mactavish

BETWEEN:

GEOFFREY W. HODGSON,

MICHELLE E. MURPHY, SCOTT HARRIS, CHANTAL HARRIS, BRENT W. POIRIER, LARA F. SHECTER, JEFFREY T. BANNARD, CHRISTINE L. BANNARD, JOHN E. D. CAMERON, THERESA M. ALLEN, JENNIFER L. SCHECTER

(A.K.A. JENNIFER L. SHECTER),

JEFFREY N. BALIN,

JOHN I. CHRISTENSEN,

STEPHEN B. COULSON,

STEFANIA G. CICCONE,

CRISTINA M. CICCONE,

WAN H. JUNG, KUEI S. FU, HENRY SCHROEDER, JERRY JANES, DIANA JANES, JIN MA, ESTATE OF HERBERT M. M. LEWIS (DECEASED), JOHN W. WHITEFOOT, SHEILA M. WHITEFOOT, DONALD A. COOKE, KAREN L. COOKE,

WONG L. LEE, MAN-LOONG LEE, MARILYN J. ROSS, WILLIAM T. ZIEMBA, JAMES R. THOMPSON, ANN B. THOMPSON, YUM C. LAU, IRENE LAU, HELEN C. L. TING, SHAVIV BEN NERIAH, SUSANA G. BEN NERIAH, CHI J. LIU, KEE L. SZE, ALI SHAH, FIKRIYE SHAH, KHI Y. TJIN,YUNG C. LIU, LISA A. RAGOSIN, MIRIAM G. WEINSTEIN, SHAUNA L. LORE, PATRICIA LAI, LUKE A. LAI, JEAN M. PATTON, SHEILA W. PATTON, BARBARA J. PATTON, PAMELA A. PATTON, BRUCE R. BAILEY, LISA J. BAILEY, JUDITH F. EYRL,

LI Q. WANG, ZHE M. YAN, QIN ZHANG, HELENA KAN, FRANCESCO L. PICCONE, MARIA C. PICCONE, ANTHONY W. L. LO, CYNTHIA LEE, NIK D. KELAVA, MARY J. KELAVA, HAN XIA, SEUK J. JANG, SEONG I. HAN, YUNG H. LIU, CAROLYN RENDLE, PREIANATHAN ARMOGAM, AMELIA F. M. HENRIKSEN, GEOFFREY LEE DESIGN & CONSTRUCTION LTD., ROBERT J. RIVINGTON, AGNIESZKA RIVINGTON, MARGARET A. C. NIELSEN, KWAN Y. LIU, AMY W. C. LIU, NICOLE L. FUNK, NORMAN D. FUNK, MIRA V. MODI, CHARLES H. SHNIER, WILLIAM V. Y. SHEN, HAPPY C. Y. SHEN, ROSS LOUKAS, GEORGIA LOUKAS, SILVIA B. NEGRONI, LAURA T. NEE, YIRK L. SO, SAU Y. SO, MOHAMED R. M. LUTHFY, SITHIE R. LUTHFY, STEPHEN D. SHAW, ELIZABETH J. L. CLARKE, JI S. LIM, CHOON M. LIM, LILY R. ENG, CAROL M. S. LAI, DONG H. KIM, HYE M. KIM, ALLAN T. OKABE, SUZANNE A. OKABE, TAMARA BELL, PAUL-SONG WU, LI ZHOU, CHRISTINE YIM HUNG SIU, YIN TAT HO

AND WALEED SUKKARIE

Plaintiffs

and

MUSQUEAM INDIAN BAND AND

HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN

IN RIGHT OF CANADA

Defendants

and

KIMBERLEY LAWSON, CHESTER LAWSON, CHERYL BURDICK, DANIEL P, ROYER, XIE SHI WANG (A.K.A. XUE SHI WANG), WILLIAM NORMAN KING, ROSALIND RAE FORD

Third Parties

JUDGMENT

WHEREAS this action came on for trial at Vancouver, British Columbia on December 5-9 and 12-16, 2016 and February 6-8, 2017;

AND UPON HEARING R.J. Randall Hordo Q.C., Howard A. Mickelson, Q.C. and Allan L. Doolittle, counsel for the Plaintiffs; Clete Purcell, Cheryl Sharvit, Crystal Reeves and Virgina Mathers, counsel for the Defendant Musqueam Indian Band; and Heather Frankson and Isabel Jackson, counsel for the Defendant Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada;

AND UPON no one appearing for the Third Parties;

AND WHEREAS at the conclusion of my Reasons for Judgment dated May 18, 2017, cited as 2017 FC 509, counsel for the plaintiffs was directed to prepare for signature a draft judgment approved as to form and content by counsel for the defendants;

THIS COURT’S JUDGMENT is that:

1.                  The fair rent to be paid annually by lessees of 75 lots in Musqueam Park for the 20-year period commencing June 8, 2015 is set out in the attached Schedule 1.

2.                  Costs to be resolved between the parties by agreement or determination upon application to the Trial Judge, with liberty to apply granted to all parties.

“Anne L. Mactavish”