LORD PHILLIMORE :—There is no dispute of fact in the case: and the sole point to be determined is whether the appellant was rightly assessed and taxed under the Income War Tax Act, 1917 (Can.), ce. 28, and the amending statute

Davies, C.J.:—We were all of the opinion at the close of the argument of the plaintiff that the appeal must be dismissed and that we are bound by our decision in the case of Abbott v. City of St. John (1908)

AUDETTE, J.:—This is an information, exhibited by the Attorney-General of Canada, whereby it appears, inter alia, that the defendant is the Minister of Agriculture for the Province of Quebec, receiving as such, a salary (R.S.Q. 1909, sec. 574), of

McKay, J.:—The information charged that the said respondent J. H. Spencer on November 15, 1920, at North Battleford, Saskatchewan, did fail to make a return of his income for the year 1917 required of him to be given pursuant to sec. 8 of the

McKay, J.:—The information charged that the said W. A. Forbes, at Grand Coulee, in the Province of Saskatchewan, on November 15, 1920, failed to make a return of his income for the year 1918, required of him to be given pursuant to sec. 8 of the

AUDETTE, J.:—This is an amended information exhibited by the Attorney-General of Canada to recover from the above defendant, by priority, the sum of $760.66 as representing the amount of income war tax due by him for the year 1917.

LATCHFORD, J.:—On the 26th November, 1919, an information was laid under oath before Mr. Kingsford, alleging that the Thompson Manufacturing Co. Ltd. did, on the 3rd November, 1919, and on every day thereunto following up to and including the 8th November,

W. H. Kerr, Q.C. (Canada), and Kenelm Digby, for the appellant in the first appeal.

Cohen, Q.C., and W. W. Kerr, for the appellant in the second appeal.

Dorion, C.J. (dissenting) :—

Per Curiam :—En 1882, la Législature de cette province a décrété, ‘‘dans le but de pourvoir aux besoins du service public,” l’imposition de certaines taxes sur les banques, les compagnies d’assurance, de télégraphe, de chemin de fer, ete., etc. La loi votée