Laliberté – Tax Court of Canada that the Cirque du Soleil’s bearing most of the $41.8M cost of a space trip for its controlling shareholder gave rise to a shareholder benefit
The founder and controlling shareholder of Cirque du Soleil was found to have received a taxable benefit under s. 15(1) (or alternatively, under s. 246(1)) equal to approximately 90% of the $41.8 million cost of sending him on a trip to the international space station in September and October 2009, given that the cost was borne by his family holding company and then largely passed through to the top operating company in the Cirque du Soleil group (whose CFO refused to deduct it for corporate income tax purposes). Boyle J stated:
I do recognize that the Cirque du Soleil promotional business-related activities in which the Appellant participated while on his trip were most probably more valuable having been from space than had they been from anywhere on earth. For that reason I could conclude that an allocation in the range of 0 to 10% of the cost of the space trip would be a reasonable charge to Cirque du Soleil. … [T]he remaining 90% of the cost of the trip, being $37.6 million, was the amount of the benefit conferred on and enjoyed by M. Laliberté.
…[T]here is a difference between a business trip which involves or includes personal enjoyment aspects, and a personal trip with business aspects, even significant ones, tacked on.
Neal Armstrong. Summary of Laliberté v. The Queen, 2018 TCC 186 under s. 15(1).